A single penalty adds 0.76 to a striker's xG tally and can make a mediocre performance look elite. Non-penalty expected goals strips that distortion away, and what you find underneath is often a very different story.
The Penalty Problem That Nobody Talks About
Expected goals is the best tool football analysis has for separating real performance from lucky results. But it has a flaw, and one significant enough to distort player rankings, mislead transfer departments, and misrepresent entire league seasons. The problem is the penalty kick.
A penalty has an xG value of approximately 0.76. That's how often they have historically gone in across thousands of kicks in professional football: about 76% of the time. So far, so logical.
The issue is what that 0.76 represents as a slice of a player's total xG. In an average Premier League match, a team generates roughly 1.5 xG from open play. A single penalty adds half of that in one moment, from a situation that tells you almost nothing about a player's attacking quality. Winning the penalty matters. The shot itself, though, is a standardised, uncontested kick from 12 yards. It carries no information about movement off the ball, link-up play, finishing technique under pressure, or anything else that characterises a striker's open-play contribution.
For teams that win many penalties, and for players who are designated penalty takers, this distortion compounds across an entire season. By the time you're looking at season totals, a prolific penalty winner can have inflated their xG by 3 to 5 goals' worth of expected output that came from the spot, not from build-up play.
What npxG Is and What It Strips Out
Non-penalty expected goals (npxG) is the simplest possible correction to this problem. Take the total xG figure and remove every penalty. What remains is npxG: a measure of expected goals from open play and non-penalty set pieces only. That's it. No complex weighting, no black box, just xG minus the contribution of penalty kicks.
The result is a cleaner signal. When you look at a player's npxG, you're seeing the chance quality they've generated from situations that actually reflect their attacking ability: arriving at the right time in the penalty area, making the right run to receive a cut-back, positioning for a headed chance from a cross, capitalising on a defensive error in transition. The calculated, uncontested penalty kick is not in the number.
For teams, the logic is identical. A club's npxG tells you how well they create chances from open play, meaning from their attacking system, their movement, and their build-up patterns. Penalties, by contrast, arrive largely at random (they depend heavily on referee decisions, opponent fouls, and match situations that don't repeat consistently). Stripping them out gives you a cleaner measure of sustainable attacking quality.
Major data providers such as Opta and StatsBomb now carry npxG alongside standard xG, and it has long been established in serious attacking analysis.
What About Penalties Won vs. Penalty Kicks Taken?
There's a subtle distinction worth making. npxG removes the xG contribution of the penalty kick itself, the 0.76 expected goals for stepping up and shooting. It says nothing about the value of winning the penalty in the first place.
Some analysts argue that winning a penalty is itself a skill: forwards like Harry Kane and Erling Haaland draw penalties at very different rates through their movement and positioning. That's legitimate. But the correct way to account for it is separately, not by including penalty xG in a metric meant to assess open-play attacking quality. The penalty won tells you about physical presence and intelligent movement in the box. The conversion rate tells you about composure under pressure. Neither belongs in a metric designed to assess open-play chance quality.
MatchAnalyzr Tip
The xG Momentum widget (Pro) tracks a team's expected goals and expected goals against (xGA) across recent matchdays. MatchAnalyzr doesn't strip penalties out of this figure, so for high-penalty teams it's worth factoring in the npxG gap when reading the trend. You'll find the npxG figure itself on the team analysis Statistics tab and per match in the Stats tab of the match popup.
Lewandowski vs. Haaland: A Study in How npxG Reframes Narratives
The clearest way to understand why npxG matters is to look at how it changes the story for specific players, particularly those who have been frequent penalty takers at various points in their careers.
Robert Lewandowski, during his peak years at Bayern Munich, was one of the most prolific xG generators in European football. He was also among the most frequent penalty takers, stepping up regularly for a team that drew fouls in the box at a high rate. In multiple seasons, the gap between his total xG and his npxG was noticeable, with several goals' worth of expected output coming from the spot rather than open play. This doesn't diminish his quality, because Lewandowski was genuinely world class in open play too. It did mean, however, that naive xG comparisons slightly overstated his output relative to forwards with fewer penalties.
Erling Haaland presents an interesting contrast. His aerial ability and explosive movement create a particular type of threat that generates high-quality chances from open play: headers in central positions and one-on-ones with the goalkeeper after breaking defensive lines. His penalty frequency has fluctuated by club and season. In periods where his penalty count was lower relative to his total output, his npxG and total xG converged, suggesting that his headline numbers genuinely reflected open-play dominance rather than spot-kick accumulation.
The comparison is instructive: two elite strikers, yet the relative gap between their npxG and xG tells you something important about the nature of their contributions. Neither is necessarily "better". They are different, though, and npxG helps you see that difference clearly.
Teams That Live on Penalties, and Teams That Don't
The distortion isn't just a player-level phenomenon. At team level, the gap between xG and npxG can reveal something important about how a club creates its chances.
Some teams win penalties at a very high rate, whether through aggressive forward runs, physical attackers who draw fouls, or simply a tactical set-up that gets them into the penalty area frequently. For these teams, a high total xG can partly reflect a penalty dependency that's strategically deliberate and potentially fragile at the same time. Referee decisions vary. Opponents adjust tactically to give away fewer fouls. A high-penalty team that faces a more physical defence, or draws a referee who's reluctant to give spot kicks, may see their attacking output drop sharply even when their open-play quality hasn't changed.
A team whose xG and npxG are nearly identical is a different case: it generates almost all of its threat from open play. That attacking performance is more clearly the product of system, movement, and technical quality. It's more robust to the randomness of penalty decisions and more clearly tied to things the coaching staff can repeat and improve.
This distinction matters enormously for pre-season recruitment. A team that wants to improve its attacking output should look at its npxG gap before deciding whether to sign a target man who draws fouls or a creative midfielder who unlocks defences. The answer depends on what the data actually shows about the source of their current attacking output.
npxG per 90: The Gold Standard for Comparing Strikers
Once the value of npxG as a concept is clear, the next step is to compare players across different clubs, leagues, and amounts of playing time. For that, you need npxG per 90 minutes, the gold standard for striker comparison in modern football analytics.
Per-90 normalisation solves the playing time problem. A striker who generates 12 npxG in 2,700 minutes (30 full games) is performing at 0.40 npxG per 90. A striker generating 8 npxG in 1,350 minutes (15 games) is performing at 0.53 npxG per 90. That's a clearly higher rate, despite the lower total. Without per-90 normalisation, you'd incorrectly rank the first player as superior based purely on volume.
For strikers specifically, npxG per 90 separates the levels roughly like this:
- Above 0.55 npxG/90: the elite, where Europe's most dangerous strikers operate
- 0.40 to 0.55 npxG/90: strong, quality starter at a Champions League club
- 0.25 to 0.40 npxG/90: solid level for the Premier League and other top flights
- Below 0.25 npxG/90: may struggle to hold down a starting place at elite level
These bands shift depending on league and role. A deep-lying forward or a second striker will typically show lower npxG/90 than a true number nine. As a rough orientation they're still useful. The critical thing is always comparing within similar contexts: same league tier, same playing position, similar team strength.
MatchAnalyzr Tip
The Per-Match xG widget (Pro) shows your selected players' xG for individual matches, plus the season-long gap between actual goals and total xG. For any standout numbers, also check how many of those goals were penalties. That helps you narrow down whether someone is genuinely above or below expectations in open play.
League-Level Analysis: Which Leagues Award More Penalties?
Penalty frequency isn't consistent across European leagues, and this has a direct impact on how much npxG and total xG diverge at league level.
Historically, Serie A has been among the higher-penalty European leagues. Behind that sits a combination of attacking runs into the box, high foul rates among defenders, and refereeing styles that have at various points been generous with spot kicks. La Liga, particularly in the years dominated by Cristiano Ronaldo and Lionel Messi (both frequent penalty takers), has seen significant penalty-derived xG in its team numbers.
The Bundesliga and the Premier League tend to fall somewhere in the middle. Individual seasons can still skew sharply, though, when league-wide refereeing directives around handball rules produce unusual penalty spikes.
Why does this matter for cross-league comparison? If you're comparing a Bundesliga striker to a Serie A striker using total xG, you need to account for the fact that the Serie A player may be operating in a higher-penalty environment, even if their open-play quality is comparable. npxG per 90 takes exactly that out of the equation, giving you a fairer cross-league comparison that's less dependent on the penalty culture of the particular competition. This is an underappreciated benefit of npxG in transfer scouting, especially when clubs are evaluating players across multiple leagues simultaneously.
How npxG Changes Transfer Valuations and Scouting Decisions
The practical stakes of npxG are highest in the transfer market. Recruitment departments now routinely use npxG when evaluating strikers. The reason: it identifies players whose goal threat genuinely comes from open play rather than penalty accumulation.
Consider the transfer calculus. A striker with 20 goals in a season looks spectacular. But if eight of those were penalties, you need to ask two questions. First: will they continue winning penalties at that rate in a new team (different system, different style, different forward partners)? Possibly not. Second: when they're not converting penalties, how dangerous are they? The npxG number answers the second question directly.
The flip side is just as revealing. A striker who consistently scores more non-penalty goals than their npxG suggests, outperforming their expected output from open play, may be an elite finisher. Or they may be on a finishing run that's unlikely to last. npxG gives you the expectation and non-penalty goals give you the outcome. The gap between the two is finishing quality, and sustained outperformance of npxG over multiple seasons is one of the clearest signals of a genuinely clinical striker.
Data-driven clubs like Brentford therefore don't recruit on goal tallies alone. They look at who consistently generates high-quality chances and evaluate finishing separately. It's a more stable, more predictive approach to identifying attacking talent.
MatchAnalyzr Tip
The xG Table (Pro) ranks the league by expected goals instead of points. It still includes penalty xG, so clubs that have won a lot of spot kicks sit a little higher than their open-play attacking quality alone would justify.
npxG in the xG Table: How League Standings Change
One of the most revealing applications of npxG is recalculating the expected goals league table with penalties removed. The xG table already tends to tell a different story from the actual standings: it shows which clubs are genuinely playing well and which are finishing above or below their underlying quality. The npxG table takes this further.
In a typical Premier League season, swapping total xG for npxG can shift several clubs by a position or two. Teams that have drawn many penalties, particularly those with physical strikers or aggressive runs into the box, will drop in the npxG table relative to their total xG ranking. Teams that create most of their threat from open play will remain roughly where they are.
For clubs near the relegation zone, this distinction can be particularly meaningful. A team that sits narrowly above the drop on total xG might be right in the danger zone once penalties are removed, because their supposed "safety cushion" was partly built on spot kicks that may not recur. Conversely, a team with good npxG that struggles to win penalties might be better placed than their total xG ranking suggests.
In the title race, the npxG table often gives the most reliable signal of which teams are genuinely playing the most dangerous football, irrespective of referee decisions.
xG or npxG: Which Should You Use?
The answer, as with most good questions in football analytics, is that it depends on what you're trying to understand.
Use total xG when:
- You want to assess overall match performance, because penalties are real events that affect results
- You're evaluating a team's total threat in a specific game
- You're looking at short-term result prediction, where penalties are a legitimate source of goals
- You want to understand why a scoreline was what it was
Use npxG when:
- You're comparing player quality across different roles, clubs, or leagues
- You're assessing a team's underlying attacking system and open-play quality
- You're doing medium-to-long-term performance assessment where penalty rates may not persist
- You're scouting players for transfer and want a stable signal of open-play attacking contribution
- You're building a league table of underlying performance rather than accounting for all goal sources
The nuanced answer is that experienced analysts use both. Total xG explains results and performance in a single match. npxG measures sustainable quality and allows fair player comparison. Neither metric is "right" in the abstract. They measure slightly different things, and both are useful depending on the question you're asking.
For most practical scouting and comparison purposes, npxG per 90 is the metric experienced analysts reach for first. It best answers the question: how dangerous is this player or team when the game is actually being played?
Frequently Asked Questions
What does npxG stand for?
npxG stands for non-penalty expected goals. It is calculated by taking a player's or team's total expected goals (xG) figure and subtracting the xG contribution of any penalty kicks. In practice, each penalty carries an xG value of approximately 0.76, so npxG = total xG minus (0.76 × number of penalties taken). The result is a measure of expected goals from open play and non-penalty set pieces only.
Why is npxG considered more accurate than xG for player comparison?
Standard xG includes penalty kicks, which have a fixed xG value of around 0.76 regardless of who takes them or how well they're playing. This means a striker who takes many penalties will have an inflated total xG that doesn't reflect their open-play quality. npxG removes this distortion, making it a fairer comparison metric across players who take different numbers of penalties. It's particularly important when comparing players across different clubs or leagues where penalty frequencies vary significantly.
What is a good npxG per 90 for a striker?
In the Premier League and other top European leagues, strong strikers usually sit between 0.40 and 0.55 npxG per 90 minutes. A number above 0.55 places a player among the top strikers in Europe. Figures between 0.25 and 0.40 are solid for a regular top-flight starter. Below 0.25 over a sustained period usually indicates that a striker is either playing in a limited role or struggling to get into quality positions. Always compare within the same league tier and playing position.
Does a large gap between xG and npxG mean a player is penalty-dependent?
A large gap at first only means that penalties represent a significant portion of a player's expected goal output, but "penalty-dependent" needs careful interpretation. Winning penalties can itself be a repeatable skill, reflecting good movement in the box and the ability to draw fouls. The key question is whether the npxG figure is strong enough to justify the player's role even without the penalty contribution. A striker with excellent npxG who also wins many penalties is doubly valuable. A striker whose value primarily comes from penalty conversion is more fragile, especially after a change of club or when opponents adapt tactically.
Do all data providers calculate npxG the same way?
The core calculation is the same across providers (total xG minus penalty xG), but the underlying xG models vary. StatsBomb, Opta, and other providers use different input variables and historical datasets to calculate the xG value of each shot, which means the npxG figures across providers won't be identical. For this reason, you should always compare npxG numbers within the same data source rather than mixing figures from different providers. The relative rankings between players will generally be consistent even when absolute numbers differ slightly.
Custom analysis dashboardsCustom team and player comparisons
With MatchAnalyzr, you call the shots. Build custom analysis dashboards from over 90 widgets for the leagues, teams and players you follow. Compare teams or players using exactly the widgets your analysis needs.